Suggestions
Hi Jiahong Chen
Great page! It is quite an interesting topic. Some suggestions and questions:
- In the introduction you have mentioned "And then choose top-K companies from those centrality method results, where k should be larger than K." How does k differ from K?
- In the Graph Notation Examples m =12 (counting (symmetric) directed links), are you considering 2-way edges making it 6*2=12 ?
- I wasn't able to visualize how projection works. Maybe a figure would have helped!
- In the Degree Centrality section v is the number of nodes, what is deg(v)?
- Is possible that you provide a link for the data set?
- In table 2, do the nodes refer to companies?
- Is there any reference for the tail of the data containing a lot of noise?
- You can put an external link for Spearman`s rank correlation.
- Figure 8 is a little small. You might consider increasing the size.
Great job on the methodology, results and case study.
Hi Samprity,
Thank you for your kindly critique!
1) the difference between k and K is that they are different variables, it seems it would be better to choose another expression to not confuse them.
2) Yes, it is a 2-way edges as considering it as a directed graph.
3) I will try to find out a figure that represents it.
4) deg(v) it the degree of that point, and it will be the in-degree and out-degree if it is a directed graph.
5) Sorry, it is not a open source data.
6) Yes, they are companies.
7) Thank you! I forgot to add the reference, will add it soon.
8) Sure! Will add it soon.
9) Did you mean the figure Other "Important" Companies In China? Figure 8 seem like figure 7 and I suppose it might be big enough. I will increase the scale of figure Other "Important" Companies In China.
Thank you again for your kindly suggestions! I will correct all these errors soon.
Best regards,
Jiahong Chen