Course:FNH200/Projects/2023/Differences in Olive Oil Processing, Labelling, & Packaging in India and Canada
Introduction
Both India and Canada have experienced a tremendous increase in the production and use of olive oil. However, clear differences between the two nations' processing, labelling, and packaging practices have arisen. This essay explores the complex intricacies that distinguish the olive oil industry in these geographically apart countries.
Olive oil has gained popularity as a healthier alternative in India, a country with rich culinary traditions, leading to an increase in production and import. Here, processing processes frequently mix contemporary technology with age-old ways to produce distinctive flavour profiles. However, challenges arise in ensuring adherence to global quality standards, raising questions about accurate labelling and appropriate packaging practices.
Contrarily, strict laws control processing, labelling, and packaging in Canada, where the olive oil market has grown due to rising health awareness. Greater consumer confidence is a result of stricter quality control measures that guarantee product integrity. The labelling requirements strongly emphasise providing precise nutritional information and information about the product's provenance, further separating Canadian olive oil from its Indian rival.
By examining the processing methods, labelling laws, and packaging strategies, this study reveals the variables causing the disparity in olive oil practices between India and Canada.
Processing
Due to differences in climatic circumstances, agricultural practises, and technical improvements, the processes used to extract olive oil in India and Canada show noticeable differences. Due to these variations, the finished products have distinctive qualities that satisfy the various preferences and needs of their respective consumer groups.
India
India's processing of olive oil frequently revolves around age-old techniques that honour the nation's rich agricultural heritage. Warm climatic areas like Rajasthan and Maharashtra are where olive growing is most common. The olives are usually manually harvested and then processed utilizing venerable methods like hydraulic pressing and stone grinding. With earthy undertones and a mildly strong flavour, this traditional method gives Indian olive oils a distinctive flavour profile.
Canada
On the other hand, Canada's production of olive oil shows the country's cutting-edge technologies and modern agricultural methods. The cultivation of olive trees in greenhouses is necessary due to the milder environment in places like British Columbia and Ontario. The extraction procedures involve centrifugation and cold pressing after the olives are collected using a combination of human and automated methods. These modern methods protect the delicate qualities of the olives, giving Canadian olive oils a smoother, more subdued flavour and a gentler scent.
Legal requirements and certifications also influence the inequalities in processing. Strict quality controls ensure Canada's production of premium-grade olive oils that match international standards. A changing landscape of olive oil production is the result of efforts being made in India to harmonize processing methods with international standards.
Labelling
The labelling requirements for Olive Oil in Canada and India have a few similarities such as displaying net quantity, identity and place of business, ingredients, nutritional information, and durable life. Our research focusses on highlighting the key additional differences in labelling requirements across the two countries.
.jpg)
India
1. Use of Specific words: The use of specific words such as, “Super refined”, “Extra-refined”, “Micro-Refined”, “Double-Refined”, Ultra-Refined”, “Anti-Cholesterol”, “Cholesterol Fighter”, “Soothing to Heart”, “Cholesterol Friendly”, “Saturated Fat Free” or other expressions which are an exaggeration of the quality of edible oils and fats must not be used on the label[1].
2. Argemone Oil Content: It is mandatory for every package of edible vegetable oils, including olive oil, to display, “Free from Argemone Oil” on the label[1].
3. FSSAI License Number: The Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) has made it mandatory for every food business operator in India to display the FSSAI license number on their products which certifies the safety of the food product for consumption[2].
Canada
1. Language Requirements: All the mandatory information on food labels in Canada must be presented in both the official languages, i.e., English and French. Whereas in India, this is not a mandatory requirement[3].
2. Health Claims: Displaying health claims on food labels is optional. However, when a manufacturer decides to display a health claim, it must not be misleading according to subsection 5(1) of Food and Drugs Act (FDA). The manufacturers/ importers must have substantial scientific evidence to support their claims[4].
Packaging
The packaging process of olive oil in Canada and India are quite different with both countries focusing on different aspects during packaging according to the consumer preferences.[5]
India
Olive oil production in India is concentrated mostly in Rajasthan and Gujarat[6]. Thereafter, the oil is packaged into a wide variety of containers. Packaging in the Indian olive oil market tends to emphasize on local flavours and more traditional methods of packaging which cater to a diverse range of cultures.
Diverse Packaging: In India, olive oil tends to be available in a wide range of packaging sizes which cater to not just households but also commercial consumers. This includes anywhere from small bottles to large containers.
Traditional Aesthetic: Several and olive oil brands focus on packaging designs that aim to focus more on tradition and authenticity. Labels tend to be colourful and try to connect with local consumers.
Local Flavours and Varieties. Indian olive oil brands tend to have different flavoured olive oils which are region specific. Since India is a land of many cultures, this approach leads to targeting the customers of several cultures. Visible differences in the packaging and ingredient use it can be noticed region to region.
Canada
In contrast, Canada’s olive oil industry is much smaller than India’s due to it’s colder climate. The majority of Olive oil present in Canada is imported. This imported olive oil is subject to rigorous quality checks and certifications before it is packed and distributed to consumers[7].
Dominance of Imports: Due to the dominance of import of olive oil in Canada, the emphasis is more on packaging of these imported products instead of domestic production.
Certification and Quality: Canadian consumers tend to prioritize quality and authenticity and does packaging of olive oil in Canada tends to highlight certifications such as PDO (Protected Designation of Origin) or PGI (Protected Geographical Indication) to assure the products quality.
Standardized Packaging: Packaging in Canada tends to follow standardized international formats, this is due to olive oil mainly being imported. Thus the sizes of bottles and containers other ones commonly found across several countries.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the disparities in olive oil practices between Canada and India are rooted in a blend of regulatory, climatic, and cultural practices and are multifaceted. The approach in India is characterized by a mixture of fractional techniques and modern technology, which is a reflection of it's rich agricultural heritage and diverse consumer base. India strives to harmonize processing methods with international norms, whereas Canada’s stringent laws and regulations help ensuring quality control and the consumer confidence. The olive oil industry in Canada shows a blend of strict adherence to labelling requirements, advanced technologies, and prioritizing accuracy in nutritional information. Furthermore, the packaging strategies are a reflection of these approaches, with India embracing local flavours and culture, and Canada focusing on certifying imported oils and standardizing international packaging formats and norms. Thus the intricate differences in processing, labelling, and packaging showcase a delicate relation between modernity, tradition, and regulation in shaping the olive oil industries of these two geographically distant countries.
Potential Exam Question
What are the mandatory labelling requirements in Canada?
✓ Principal Place of Business
X Business Number
✓ Billingual Information
✓ Net Quantity
This question recaps lesson 4.3 which highlights the mandatory labelling requirements for food products as set out by Canada Food Inspection Agency in the Consumer Packaging and Labelling Act and Regulations. As consumers, it is important for everyone to know the mandatory labelling requirements for food producers and check the details before buying any product.
References
Your team reflection, one submission per team, should be submitted on Canvas.