Preservation of Foods by Low Temperature
Overview In this lesson you will learn about the principles that form the basis for extending the storage life of foods through the use of low temperatures above and below the freezing point of water. You will also learn about chilled storage of perishable foods and the use of modified and controlled atmospheres to extend the storage life of foods.
You will learn about the importance of freezing and thawing rates and their influence on the quality of frozen foods. The importance of ice crystal size and chemical reactions and physical changes that can occur in foods during freezing, frozen storage and thawing will be briefly discussed. You will learn about some of the methods of freezing foods and also about packaging requirements for foods held in chilled and frozen storage.
Objectives Upon completion of this lesson, you will be able to:
- Explain the principles that form the basis of extension of storage life of foods at low temperatures;
- State the importance of freezing rates, temperature stability during storage of frozen foods, and thawing rates on quality maintenance in frozen foods;
- Describe the factors that can affect quality of foods during frozen storage
Use of Low Temperatures in Food Preservation Refrigeration or cool storage generally refers to storage at temperatures above freezing, while freezing and frozen storage occur at temperatures below freezing. However, whereas pure water freezes at 0°C, most foods do not begin to freeze until a temperature of -2°C or lower is reached.
Refrigerated or cool storage generally will preserve most perishable foods for days or weeks, while good frozen storage conditions with proper packaging can preserve foods for months or even years.
It should be noted that some psychrotrophic pathogens (review terminology in Lesson 5) can grow, although slowly, at refrigerator temperatures, and some spoilage organisms can even grow at temperatures below 0°C providing that there is unfrozen water available.
Below -9.5°C, there is no significant growth of spoilage or pathogenic organisms, and there is a gradual decrease in numbers of living organisms. However, freezing and frozen storage do not lead to complete destruction, and rapid growth and multiplication can occur during thawing.
- 1 Refrigeration (Cool Storage) of Foods
- 2 Freezing and Frozen Storage of Foods
- 2.1 Freezing Point
- 2.2 Changes in Food During Freezing, Frozen Storage and Thawing
- 2.3 Factors Affecting the Quality of Frozen Foods
- 2.4 Freezing Methods
- 2.5 Packaging Considerations for Frozen Foods
- 3 References
Refrigeration (Cool Storage) of Foods
Refrigeration is one of the mildest approaches to food preservation. Cool storage of foods falls between 16°C to -2°C. However, the normal refrigeration temperatures should be in the range of 4°C and below. A drop of 10°C slows down rate of senescence by 2 to 3 times and microbial growth by 3 to 6 times. The Food and Drug Regulations of Canada state that perishable foods that can support the growth of disease-causing microorganisms must be stored at temperatures of 4°C and below.
Refrigeration temperatures inhibit the growth of most disease-causing microorganisms but favour the psychrotrophic spoilage-causing microorganisms. Some spoilage-causing microorganisms, particularly moulds, can grow at temperatures as low as -8°C.
You must keep in mind that refrigeration storage temperatures provide for only short term extensions of storage life of foods Refrigeration storage of foods cannot improve the quality of a food item that is low of quality when placed into cold storage. In addition to being a mild approach to short-term preservation, refrigeration is also sometimes applied to achieve desirable attributes of fermented food products such as cheeses, beef and wine upon cool ripening or aging.
What are the optimal conditions for refrigerated storage of foods? Each food commodity has its optimum refrigeration conditions for maximum storage life and retention of quality and nutritional value.
The storage life of meats, fish and dairy products are maximized by temperatures that approach 0°C. During refrigerated storage of foods, maintenance of controlled temperatures are very important to ensure maximum storage life of the foods and to prevent chill injury to certain foods, especially some fruits and vegetables. For example, as reported by Potter and Hotchkiss (1995):
- Bananas will undergo a colour change in the peel from yellow to black, while sweet potatoes may show decay, pitting and internal discolorations, when stored at temperatures below 13°C.
- Apples may become soggy or show internal browning if stored below 1-2°C.
- Potatoes and avocados may also become brown if stored below 5 and 7°C, respectively.
Other factors to be controlled for products in refrigerated storage are humidity and gas atmosphere composition. A very fine humidity balance must be maintained to prevent dehydration of the food while avoiding creation of conditions that are so humid that mould growth and food spoilage are favoured. Many food products are stored under controlled and modified atmospheres in conjunction with refrigerated storage for the extension of storage life.
Controlled Atmosphere Packaging
A controlled atmosphere refers to a condition in which the atmosphere surrounding a food product is different from that of the normal atmosphere, and the composition of the atmosphere around the product is constantly monitored and maintained at preset levels. Review from Lesson 1: "controlled atmosphere storage"- facilities where the atmosphere (CO2, O2 and N2), temperature (kept low) and humidity are carefully controlled to slow the rate of respiration and ripening of the apples, thus extending the storage life of the fresh fruit.
Modified Atmosphere Packaging
Modified atmosphere packaging (MAP) refers to the creation of atmospheric conditions around the product that are different from the normal atmosphere. In this type of system, food items are placed into a package. The air in the package is then removed either by drawing a vacuum, then backflushing the package with the desired gas mixture before sealing the package, or simply by flushing the package with the desired gas mixture until the air in the package is replaced by the desired gas mixture (usually a combination of carbon dioxide and nitrogen) before sealing the package. Examples of products with MA-packaging (MAP) are shown below.
The composition of the atmosphere in a modified atmosphere packed food product changes over time, the changes being governed by metabolic activities of the food, the microorganisms in the food, and the gas permeability of the packaging materials used. Peameable films are carefully designed to have the right gas permeability, water vapour transmission rate, mechanical properties, transparency and sealing reliability for the vast number of products in the market.
Vacuum packaged processed or cured meats are another example of MAP, except in this case after a vacuum is drawn once the product is put in the package, there is no backflushing with a gas mixture prior to sealing the package. These products have a much longer storage life than those stored in air. Removal of oxygen from these products through the vacuum process suppresses the growth of the aerobic spoilage-causing bacteria. This leads to the extension of the storage life of these products.
Retail cuts of cheese are often packed under vacuum or under gas mixtures to prevent the growth of moulds which are common aerobic spoilage-causing microorganisms of cheeses.
Keep in mind the fact that although food products packed under modified atmospheres have a longer storage life, those products must be kept in refrigerated storage in order to maximize the benefits of inhibition of growth of spoilage-causing microorganisms and to prevent the growth of microorganisms that may be capable of causing illness.
Changes in Food During Refrigerated Storage
Over prolonged storage, numerous undesirable changes can be observed, in addition to those brought on by microbial spoilage. These include:
- Staling of bread
- Loss of crispness in fruits and vegetables
- Change in colour of fresh meat
- Loss of flavour and nutrient value (e.g. vitamins)
- Oxidative changes
- Drip (water loss, syneresis) from fish
Freezing and Frozen Storage of Foods
Freezing provides longer shelf life of food. It is carried out at temperatures well below 0°C. In fact, commercial freezing requires a minimum of -18°C. Household freezers only reach temperatures of -12 to -14°C. The basis for preservation by freezing/frozen storage is that freezing permits longer term storage than refrigerated storage due to:
- Lower temperatures used (remember that microorganisms can not grow well at temperatures below -9.5°C)
- Lower water activity (by freezing the "free" water present in the food)
Both factors slow down chemical and enzymatic reactions as well as microbial growth. (Keep in mind that physical, chemical & enzymatic changes may still take place, especially if freezing and frozen storage conditions are not optimal.)
Freezing slows/stops microbial growth. However, storage of food at freezing temperatures does not kill all microorganisms and in fact many disease-causing and spoilage-causing microorganisms can survive in frozen foods for many years (e.g. Listeria monocytogenes). Once the food is thawed, the surviving microorganisms can resume their growth and function, causing disease or spoilage if the proper conditions for microbial growth prevail.
When freezing of food is properly done, it can preserve the quality of the food without causing major changes in appearance, texture and flavour. Frozen foods are generally of higher nutritional and aesthetic quality than thermally processed foods. The faster the rate of freezing, the better the retention of quality, both sensory and nutritional. The effect of freezing and other preservation methods on nutrient quality will be discussed later in the course (Lesson 11).
Whether food is frozen in your home or in a food processing plant, the same principles govern the maintenance of quality during freezing and frozen storage.
What does "freezing point" mean? Although the freezing point of pure water is 0°C, actually water does not begin to freeze until it is supercooled to several degrees below 0°C and start to crystallize. Once water starts to crystallize, there is an abrupt rise in temperature due to the evolution of the latent heat of fusion or crystallization. Only after all the water has frozen (crystallized) will the temperature approach the temperature of the freezing environment.
What is the freezing point of pure water? ...of water in foods?
Although the freezing point of pure water is 0°C, the freezing point of foods is somewhat below 0°C, the freezing point of pure water, because foods contain solutes dissolved in the aqueous (water) phase. The dissolved solutes have the net effect of lowering the freezing point of foods by several degrees Celsius.
Note that water is frozen out as pure water. Until all of the water is frozen, there is an ever-increasing concentration of water-soluble solutes in the unfrozen phase In fact, there is a considerable proportion of unfrozen water at temperatures below 0°C.
How much water remains unfrozen?
This depends both on the temperature as well as the food product itself. For example, for beef, 70% of the water remains in the unfrozen state at -4oC, compared to 3% and only trace amounts at -9 and -18°C, respectively.
From this description you will begin to appreciate that many complex changes occur within food systems as the freezing operation is carried out.
Changes in Food During Freezing, Frozen Storage and Thawing
You may have had the unfortunate experience of placing a beverage or other container of liquid food in a freezer to chill it quickly, only to find the container has cracked or the lid popped off because of the expansion of the water in the food as the water froze. The same phenomenon occurs within the cells of food during freezing if the conditions are not carefully controlled. Rupture of cell walls and membranes during freezing and thawing can lead to formation of drip when the product is thawed. The process of freezing foods has great influence on the ultimate quality of the food once it is thawed and prepared for consumption. Changes that occur in foods during freezing, storage and thawing can be both chemical and physical in nature.
Various chemical, enzymatic and physical changes are promoted as a result of the concentration of components (concentration effects) in the unfrozen water phase within the frozen foods. For example:
- Chemical changes such as oxidative rancidity or oxidation of flavour components, pigments and vitamins.
- Enzymatic reactions such as enzymatic browning or lipolytic rancidity.
- Meats become tougher due to protein denaturation by chemical effects and cell breakage by ice crystals
In freezing foods, the objective is to promote the formation of tiny ice crystals rather than the formation of fewer but larger ice crystals that cause cellular damage. Ice crystal damage can lead to loss of water from the food product once it is thawed. The drip that is found in thawed strawberries or beef is due in part to ice crystal damage to the cells, leading to leakage of cellular fluids into extracellular spaces, and to the loss of water-holding capacity of food components as a result of concentration effects.
Emulsions and other dispersions are destabilized by the growth of numerous small ice crystals to larger, less numerous but more damaging ice crystals; such growth in ice crystal size is usually caused by temperature fluctuations.
You may have noted shrinkage and development of graininess in ice cream stored in the frost-free freezer section of your refrigerator. This is due to partial melting of the ice cream during temperature fluctuations that result from the defrost cycles. This leads to foam destabilization and crystallization of lactose as a consequence of concentration effects.
Other undesirable changes include formation of package ice and freeze dehydration which is popularly called freezer burn and can produce unsightly food surfaces and loss of nutrients. "Freezer burn" is a misnomer since the food does not "burn" in the freezer but rather takes on an appearance of having been burned because of the moisture loss that occurs during this freeze dehydration.
Factors Affecting the Quality of Frozen Foods
The type and extent of changes during freezing, frozen storage and thawing, which are directly related to the final quality of frozen foods, are affected by many factors. Here are the 4 most common ones:
- Rate of freezing
- Final storage temperature
- Stability of storage temperature, and
- Rate of thawing
Rate of Freezing
The rate of freezing of foods is very important, with rapid freezing rates being desirable since the formation of many small ice crystals is favoured. Freezing rates vary depending on the composition and physical structure of food, as this will influence the ability of food to conduct heat (an important parameter during both the freezing and thawing operations). Some food components such as fat and entrapped gases can act as insulators and impede the rate of heat transfer. Water is a poorer conductor of heat than ice. Other factors that influence the freezing rate are:
- Temperature difference: the greater the temperature difference between the food and the refrigerant, the faster the freezing rate.
- Product thickness/geometry and heat transfer rate: the thinner the food piece or greater the heat transfer rate, the faster the freezing rate.
- Air velocity: the greater the velocity of refrigerated air or circulating refrigerant, the faster the freezing rate.
- Degree of contact: the more contact between the food and the cooling medium, the faster the freezing rate.
These four factors are given great attention in the design of food freezing plants in order to maximize the rate of freezing so that quality attributes of the food commodity can be retained.
Final Storage Temperature
The final temperature for storage of frozen foods is dictated by a number of factors: texture changes, chemical reactions, etc. There are a number of reasons why the storage temperature of about -18°C is commonly used and the normal operating temperature of deep freezers sold for home use is also -18°C.
The table below shows the number of months during which high quality storage life of frozen food can be maintained at three different storage temperatures. Note how temperature has a marked influence on the storage life of frozen foods. You can see in Table 7.1 that each food commodity has its optimum storage life at -18°C. The rates of deterioration of frozen foods are governed by the chemical composition and physical structure of the foods.
Approximate Number of Months of High Quality Storage at Different Storage Temperatures. Adapted from Potter, N.N. and Hotchkiss, J.H. 1998. Cold Preservation and Processing (Ch. 9). In Food Science, 5th ed. Chapman and Hall, N.Y. p. 180.
|Products||- 18 °C||- 12 °C||- 6.7 °C|
|Peaches||12||< 2.0||6 days|
|Spinach||6 - 7||< 3.0||1|
|Chicken (Raw)||27||15.5||< 8.0|
|Beef (Raw)||13 - 14||5.0||< 2.0|
|Pork (Raw)||10||< 4.0||< 1.5|
|Lean Fish (Raw)||3.0||< 2.0||< 1.5|
|Fat Fish (Raw)||2.0||1.5||24 days|
|Turkey Pies||> 30||< 9.5||< 2.5|
Stability of the Storage Temperature
As important as the storage temperature is the stability of the storage temperature. It is important to note that as the temperature of the frozen food increases, the amount of unfrozen water increases. Thus small fluctuations in storage temperature can cause melting of small ice crystals with subsequent refreezing of the liquid water on to other small ice crystals as the temperature drops, leading to the formation of fewer but larger ice crystals which can produce negative changes in the food quality.
For example, garden peas and corn kernels are frozen individually at the vegetable processing plant. When the package is picked up the contents should feel like a bag of marbles. Often when we purchase frozen peas in the retail store, those peas are presented as a solid block. Why does this change in physical appearance occur?
Rate of Thawing
The rate of thawing of frozen foods is as critical to quality maintenance as the rate of freezing. Maximum quality retention is achieved by rapid thawing rates. Since ice is a good conductor of heat (it has a high thermal diffusivity) the temperature of a frozen food rapidly approaches the melting point of ice. After the rapid initial temperature increase, subsequent increases in temperature occur very slowly because of the need to supply the latent heat of fusion1 for the conversion of water from the crystalline state to the liquid state at 0°C.
Latent heat is the quantity of heat required to change the state or condition under which a substance exists, without changing its temperature (Potter and Hotchkiss, 1995).
There are three major methods of freezing foods:
- Still-air 'sharp' freezer
- Air blast freezer
- Fluidized-bed freezer (IQF)
Indirect Contact Freezing
- Single plate
- Double plate
- Pressure plate
- Slush freezer
Immersion and Cryogenic Freezing
- Heat exchange fluid
- Compressed gas
- Refrigerant spray
Air Blast Freezing
Air freezing is the oldest and most common type of freezing used. The freezer section of your household refrigerator and the deep freezer are examples of still air freezers or low air velocity systems.
Air blast freezing is a moderately fast freeze because of vigorous circulation of cold air. The product is placed on trays or mesh belts and passed slowly through an insulated tunnel. In different systems the temperature may range from -18°C to -34°C, with an air velocity of 100-3500 lineal feet per minute, with a counter current air flow.
Air blast freezers operate at lower temperatures than still air freezers and rely on movement of the cold air at high velocity over the food in order to achieve rapid removal of heat and to maximize the freezing rate.
Garden peas and individually quick frozen shrimp or prawns are frozen in fluidized-bed freezers. In this type of air freezing, solid particles ranging in size from peas to strawberries are being exposed through a movement of the cold air (-18°C to -34°C) at high velocity as they pass along a conveyor belt. This will impart a vibratory motion to food particles, accelerating the freezing rate. The cold air being forced upward through the bed lifts and suspends the food particles, thus fluidization occurs. In this way, a rapid freezing rate is accomplished and an IQF (individually quick frozen) product is produced. In other words, food items are frozen as individual pieces and are not stuck together.
The garden peas, corn and other IQF products are packaged after freezing. If garden peas, or any other food product that is stated to be IQF on the package label, are present in the package as a solid block, this indicates that the product has undergone partial thawing and refreezing during storage, distribution, retailing, or on the way home from the retail store to your home.
There are several good Youtube Videos that demonstrate how produces are frozen by fluidized-bed freezers. Search one using 'IQF', 'freezing', 'blueberries', 'carrot', and/or 'corn' as your key words.
Indirect Contact Freezers
Indirect Contact freezers are used in the production of various frozen food commodities. In these freezers, food is placed on belts or trays and a refrigerant circulates through a wall beside the food. As the food comes into "contact" with the cold wall, it quickly cools down and freezes. Plate and slush freezers are some examples of indirect contact freezers.
During plate freezing food products are placed in contact with a metal surface which is cooled by a cold brine, or a vaporizer refrigerant such as ammonia. The packaged food either rests on, slides against or is pressed between the cold metal plates. These plates maintain firm contact with two major surfaces of packages to facilitate heat transfer and prevent bulging of the packages during the freezing process. Fish sticks and frozen fish fillets are commonly frozen in plate contact freezers.
Another type of indirect contact freezer is the slush freezers or scraped surface heat exchangers. These freezers can be used only for fluid food products. A common example of a scraped surface freezer is the machine used to convert ice cream mix to soft ice cream in restaurants and ice cream shops. The same principle is used in the commercial production of ice cream that is sold as hard ice cream. In the case of ice cream, the rotator not only aids in promoting rapid freezing and the development of small ice crystals, but it also aids in the incorporation of air bubbles into the freezing mix which results in the formation of a solid foam (review definition of a solid foam from Lesson 2).
Immersion and Cryogenic Freezing
Immersion freezing involves the immersion of packaged or un-packaged food products directly in a non-toxic refrigerant fluid. The refrigerant fluids commonly used are propylene glycol, glycerol, sodium chloride, calcium chloride, and mixtures of salt and sugar. Canned citrus juice, turkeys and chickens are often frozen in immersion freezing units. Ice cream popsicles can also be frozen using this method.
Cryogenic freezing is accomplished with cryogenic liquids, with liquid nitrogen being the most commonly used. This is a very rapid freezing method in which un-packaged or thinly packaged foods are exposed to extremely cold freezant. In contrast to the liquid immersion freezing, heat removal is accomplished during a change of state by the freezant. Products such as TV dinners, preformed hamburger patties and other high value food products are frozen in cryogenic freezers because of the excellent retention of quality imparted by the rapid rate of freezing and small ice crystal formation. The figure on the right illustrates a cryogenic process.
How does liquid nitrogen cryogenic freezing work?
The product is first placed on a conveyor belt and is moved into the pre-cooling part of the freezing unit. Once the food is cooled, the food is sprayed by liquid nitrogen as it is being moved through the conveyor belt; here is where the freezing process takes place, by the nitrogen boiling as it contacts the food. Finally, the food is allowed to equilibrate to the desired final temperature (between -18°C to -30°C).
Summary of Advantages and Disadvantages
Air blast freezing; Fluidize-bed freezing (IQF)
- Can freeze various sizes and shapes of food
- IQF has more efficient heat transfer, increased rate of freezing
- Possible excess dehydration (freezer burn)
- Undesirable bulging of the packages (by expansion of the product) may occur
- Non-uniform products can not be fluidized (IQF) easily
Indirect Contact Freezing
- Minimal dehydration
- Minimal package bulging
- Slow freezing process
- Products must be of uniform thickness
Immersion/ Cryogenic Freezing
- Rapid freezing process
- Almost no dehydration
- Oxygen is excluded, decreasing oxidative spoilage
- Individual freezing pieces have less freezing damage
- Difficult to find suitable freezants
- Cost of operating is high
Packaging Considerations for Frozen Foods
Packaging materials to be used for frozen foods must be resistant to the transfer of water vapour from the food to the dry environment within the freezing unit. The packaging material must not shatter in the cold temperatures encountered in frozen storage.
You will note that glass is not a good material for packaging frozen foods because it tends to shatter and it is not flexible.
The packaging material should resist the formation of pinholes during normal handling. Breaches in the packaging material will promote the development of freezer burn on the exposed areas of the food. Depending on the food, the packaging material may have to possess barrier properties toward light and/or oxygen.
FNH 200 Course content on this wiki page and associated lesson pages was originally authored by Drs. Brent Skura, Andrea Liceaga, and Eunice Li-Chan. Ongoing edits and updates are contributed by past and current instructors including Drs. Andrea Liceaga, Azita Madadi-Noei, Nooshin Alizadeh-Pasdar, and Judy Chan.